Tropical Health Matters

According to MinahHAli, polio is still with us as seen in this posting about polio challenges in the class blog of the course, Social and Behavioral Foundations of Primary Health Care at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health

Image Source: UNHCR

After a much-desired decrease of polio cases in Pakistan, the recent increase in cases reported has been alarming. This latest surge coincided with the Afghan Refugee Crisis in Pakistan, showcasing the impact of government policies in the success of polio eradication.

What is Polio? Polio, also known as poliomyelitis, is a viral disease which affects nerves in the spinal cord or brain stem leading to paralysis and death in some cases. Poliovirus rapidly spreads either via feces or droplets from coughing/sneezing. Polio mainly affects unvaccinated children.

Why are Polio vaccination initiatives focused on Pakistan and Afghanistan? Are all polio cases the same? Pakistan and Afghanistan are the last two countries in the world which consistently report polio cases. Despite spending $9.3 billion over the course of 10 years (2013-2023) polio cases remain present in Pakistan.  According to WHO, Polio cases in Afghanistan can be traced back to one variant: YB3A. However, recently polio cases in Pakistan are now also from YB3A variant.

Image Source: CNN

What is the Afghan Refugee Crisis and how is it fueling the spread of polio? Pakistan is the largest host country for Afghan refugees since 1979 post-Soviet invasion. In 2019, Ministry of National Health Services, Regulation and Coordination in Pakistan, along with UNHCR, promised healthcare which included polio vaccination to Afghan refugees. However, due to increased security threats recently near the Pak-Afghan border these efforts have stopped.

Due to attacks on Pakistani soil which have been linked to Afghan terrorist groups, the Federal Government of Pakistan is currently forcibly relocated Afghan refugees back to Afghanistan. Due to this, many Afghans refugees refuse to seek healthcare in the fear of being reported and deported.

Why are the polio eradication programs failing? The political climate in Pakistan, especially in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province which borders Afghanistan, is tense; heightened insecurity, fueled with tribal conflicts amongst Pakistanis and Afghanis residing in the area is making polio vaccination programs “almost impossible”, according to polio eradication lead at Bill and Melinda Gates foundation.

By neglecting the on-going polio spread amongst Afghan refugees, Poliovirus is making its way into Pakistani citizens/communities.  It is imperative that the Ministry of National Health Services, Regulation and Coordination, as well as the provincial Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Government increase their efforts for polio vaccination- regardless of immigration status.

On August 20, 2024, Yasir Ahmed Posted this blog about polio challenges in the class blog of the course, Social and Behavioral Foundations of Primary Health Care at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health

Pakistan and Afghanistan are the only countries in the world reporting wild type polio virus cases. Polio is a crippling disease that does not have any cure but it is preventable through immunization. The detection of wild-type virus in wastewater suggests 2024 target of ending all wild virus transmission will be missed. 6 cases were reported in 2023 and 14 have been reported this year so far.  According to a report by IMB, an estimated 300,000 children have been consistently missed in vaccination activities in Pakistan and in the East region of Afghanistan. Disinformation, false beliefs and mistrust on the government and administration, refusal, not understanding the importance of vaccines, and low general literacy and health literacy etc. are among the important factors contributing to these missed opportunities.

In addition to the above-mentioned factors, insecurity, movement across the porous 2400 kilometers long Pakistan-Afghan border, and poor water and sanitation and waste management are the contributing factors. I believe that the missed opportunities to reach and vaccinate these children has a major role in the spread of poliovirus along with poor water and sanitation in these areas.

The program uses four distinct risk tiers to classify areas according to the risk they present and to devise risk appropriate strategies. Core reservoir districts (or Tier 1 districts), high-risk districts (or Tier 2 districts), vulnerable districts (or Tier 3 districts), and low-risk districts (or Tier 4 districts). Most of the tier 1 and tier 2 areas are located on the western border aka Pakistan-Afghan border (upper parts on the map).

Pakistan Polio Eradication Program is an initiative that is driven by the largest surveillance network in the world (up to 339,521 trained and dedicated polio workers), quality data collection and analysis, behavioral change communication, laboratories, and epidemiologists and public health experts in Pakistan, working with experts and local and international stakeholders. The government started National Emergency Action Plan for Polio Eradication in 2010, which runs supplemental immunization activities on regular basis to reach every child in Pakistan. As a result, a huge decline in the number of polio cases is seen since the 90’s. The World Health Organization (WHO) and UNICEF along with other key partners of the Global Polio Eradication Initiative, has been a very supportive to the Government of Pakistan in polio eradication. Gavi the vaccine alliance, the Center of Disease Control (CDC), Rotary International, and Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation are important stakeholders that provides major financial, technical and field support.

A Polio-worker is pictured giving an oral polio vaccine during an immunization campaign.

Innovative approaches are required to reach the children missing vaccinations including:

• Expanding the network and improving data collection and surveillance, targeting the areas of high density with polio cases e.g., the tribal areas along the porous Pak-Afghan border.
• Mandatory vaccination at border crossing.
• Increased security for the polio workers.
• Taking local religious and community leaders and scholars on-board to counter disinformation and false beliefs.
• Continuation and strengthening of National Emergency Action Plan for Polio Eradication by the government of Pakistan.

Continued efforts and support from the local and international stakeholders as we are getting very close global polio eradication.

The class blog for Social and Behavioral Foundations of PHC features a posting by Alice Calhoun on the importance of pilot implementation of the new malaria vaccine in Kenya. Her comments are found below.

Since 2019, significant improvements in death rates and hospitalizations from malaria in young children have been made in Kenya after initiating the pilot malaria vaccine trial, Malaria Vaccine Implementation Programme (MVIP) involving children under 2 years old. Under the leadership and support from WHO, GAVI, and PATH and many other stakeholders, Kenya was able to benefit from the RTS,S vaccine that was developed for over 35 years by GlaxoSmithKline Pharmaceuticals. As the vaccination program continues in Western Kenya, parents in Vihiga County have noted that their children who have been vaccinated are less sick than their older siblings. The 4 part vaccination series typically begins at age 6 months with its completion at 24 months.

Malaria prevention must have a multi-faceted approach to be successful in eradicating this terrible disease from the community. This includes using insecticide treated bednets, indoor spraying, rapid diagnosis and treatment of active malaria, and malaria prevention during pregnancy. By using education and collaboration with groups such as the Kenya Malaria Youth Army, community health workers (CHW) are the key to disseminating information to the villages and encouraging mothers to complete the series for their children. CHW are also providing catch up vaccinations for other diseases while supporting the malaria campaign in Kenya by handing out bednets.

Now is the time for the Ministry of Health (MOH) to expand the vaccine program to all children under 5 years of age, some of whom missed out on the initial set of vaccines due to vaccine hesitancy during the COVID pandemic. The benefits have been seen by the community in Vihiga County and the attitudes of the mothers are now overwhelmingly positive. Due to the dedication of the CHW and the Immunization Coordinator, nurse Edith Anjere, Vihiga County has the highest rate of childhood immunization coverage in Kenya: up to 96% of children as surveyed in 2022.

Vihiga County is the perfect community to capture more children in the vaccination program since the health infrastructure is already in place as well as an openness in the community to continue vaccinating our children. The MOH can support this nationwide campaign against malaria by allowing other vulnerable children access to RTS,S in Vihiga County, serving as a model program for other counties. Kenya has been at the forefront of the malaria vaccination program and will continue to inspire other countries in Africa to work toward this goal of keeping our most vulnerable citizens healthier.

 

The term “vaccine hesitancy” is relatively new jargon that is defined in Wikipedia as, “… a delay in acceptance, or refusal, of vaccines despite the availability of vaccine services and supporting evidence.” The World Health Organization considers Vaccine Hesitancy among the top 10 threats to global public health. Vaccine hesitancy is primarily a matter of trust in institutions, technology, government, and health workers among others, according to Unfried and Priebe. Thus, hesitancy has social and political dimensions. This public health concern now extends into the realm of malaria control and elimination.

After many years of testing for efficacy and implementability, we now have two malaria vaccines. Therefore, it is not surprising that the issue of hesitancy has been identified as a potential challenge. Hussein et al. studied parents in Ghana and found that “About one-third (34.5%) of the parents were hesitant to give their children the R21/Matrix-M malaria vaccine,” even though “showed a high safety and efficacy level, and Ghana is the first country to approve this new vaccine.” It seems that parents who had not been getting routine vaccinations for their children were among those who were more hesitant.

The experience with door-to-door oral polio vaccine outreach campaigns from twenty plus years ago, shows that the general problem of avoidance or reluctance is nothing new,  but often rooted in political and cultural factors, according to Jegede. Covid-19 has shed new light on the problem as explained in the Lancet: “COVID-19 vaccines to low-income and middle-income countries (LMICs) is threatened by vaccine hesitancy. In Africa in particular, the low vaccine coverage and the ubiquitous vaccine hesitancy in a concerning proportion of the population undermine efforts to fight the COVID-19 pandemic.”

It should be noted that the term ‘hesitancy’ puts the blame for not vaccinating children and others on community members and health care consumers. When the expanded program on immunization started 50 years ago, there was recognition that reasons for seeking or not obtaining vaccines were multifaceted and included much more than consumer knowledge and attitudes. Health system factors and economic barriers were of equal concern. We need to return to those days when we took a holistic view on how to promote vaccine uptake.

Low levels of vaccine overage go beyond trust. When the Wikipedia definition mentions “despite the availability” there is the assumption that in fact vaccines are available, which is a major logistics, economics, and systems challenge. Fortunately, Mutombo et al. in the Lancet stress the other factors for low vaccine coverage including “historical, structural, and other systemic dynamics that underpin vaccine hesitancy.” They address serious supply problems wherein the global community has not made a “firm commitment to expedite vaccine deployment to the African continent.” It is not surprising that Nigeria has the highest level of unmet demand for COVID-19 vaccines in the world. Wollburg et al. also note that “Many who are willing to get vaccinated are deterred by a lack of easy access to vaccines at the local level.”

Concerning the two malaria vaccines, UNICEF notes that “It is clear that the demand is very high and far surpasses the supply that is expected to become available.” Concerns revolve around production capacity, supply chain management, integration within the health system’s existing immunization programs, pricing, and partnerships. While it is useful to plan ways to counteract hesitancy, such efforts will not be relevant is there is inadequate supply to meet current and projected demand and needs. As Gavi explains, “partners will also work with countries to provide orientation and technical assistance to ensure quality planning and country readiness.”

David Kanamugire has published a blog on the need to add the malaria vaccine to Tanzania’s arsenal of malaria elimination strategies. The original posting is found in the class blog for the Social & Cultural Basis for Community and Primary Health Programs class at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health. Below is his perspectives on the issue.

Malaria is still a major public health problem. In 2021, malaria killed an estimated 619,000 people – 95 percent of them in Africa. Children under the age of 5 accounted for 80 percent of Africa malaria deaths. Tanzania is among 4 countries that account for just over half of all global malaria deaths.

The country has significantly reduced malaria cases, from a prevalence of 18% in 2008 to 8.1% in 2022. This reduction is attributed to intervention such as Insecticide Treated bed Nets, Indoor Residual Spray, effective drugs and Malaria Rapid Diagnostic tests.

But recently the global progress on malaria has stalled and this could be due to emerging drug resistance, insecticide resistance and the spreading of invasive species Anopheles stephensi. For the past 3 years, the global malaria death remains above 600,000. Therefore there is need for new approaches to help in efforts to prevent and control malaria.

Photo: Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance

Vaccines are safe and cost-effective way combat communicable diseases and improve health outcomes. One of malaria vaccine that have been approved by the WHO is R21. It was developed by Oxford and is produced at a large scale by the Serum Institute of India.

The R21 vaccine is cheap and can be easily produced thus making it ideal for Africa countries. The R21 is also effective against malaria as three initial doses followed by a booster give up to 80 percent protection against malaria.

World Malaria Day 2023 is focusing on three key themes, Investment, Innovation, and Implementation, the 3 I’s. The recently approved malaria vaccines and those still under development embody these themes fully.  They all represent decades of investment in innovation, research, and now implementation.

After extensive several decades of clinical research and three years of field implementation in Ghana, Malawi, and Kenya by the World Health Organization and National Malaria and Immunization Programs, the RTS,S/AS01 malaria vaccine is being rolled out with assistance of GAVI, the Global Vaccine Alliance. During the malaria vaccine implementation program (MVIP) and also based on GAVI’s philosophy for vaccine programs generally, a key strategy was to provide RTS,S as routine immunization services alongside other essential services including a comprehensive package of malaria control and elimination interventions. RTS,S is not only being made available to the three MVIP countries, but as supplies come on board, other falciparum malaria endemic countries have started to apply for supplies and funding through GAVI.

It was well known from the beginning that although RTS,s might be first out the gate, other vaccines would be following closely on its heels. The benefits as well as the efficacy limitations of RTS,S were well known.  Therefore, talk was common for new products being available by 2026. Now in 2023, countries have started to move ahead on another vaccine candidate.

BBC reported that “Ghana is the first country to approve a(nother) new malaria vaccine that has been described as a ‘world-changer’ by the scientists who developed it.” R21 appears to be more effective than its predecessor, so Ghana’s drug regulators moved ahead quickly using final trial data on the vaccine’s safety and effectiveness, which is not even public, to approve it. Interestingly, this move is in parallel to the World Health Organization’s consideration of approving the vaccine.  Shortly thereafter, Nigerian medicine regulators also approved R21. Reuters noted that these “approvals are unusual as they have come before the publication of final-stage trial data for the vaccine.” The actual roll out will ultimately depend on official publication of the safety data and sourcing of funds.

As mentioned above, these malaria vaccines represented considerable investment of time and resources, embody the kind of innovation that is needed to tackle malaria as drug and insecticide resistance threaten progress toward elimination, and require detailed planning right down to the grassroots levels to ensure that a malaria vaccine delivery is part of a comprehensive package of malaria and child health services.

We need to return to the theme of investment. While international organizations, universities, ministries of health, and of course pharmaceutical companies have been investing in developing a safe, effective, and feasible product, these innovative products will not save lives until funds are invested for both purchase and service delivery are guaranteed. GAVI and Partners have put together over $200 million in support for RTS,S implementation for three years. The first window was open in September 2022 for the initial three MVIP countries, and a second window for others, depending on available supplies was open in December 2022.

Investment FOR implementation is a challenging subject because GAVI and collaborating agencies are not a bottomless well of money. What level of national investment by a country to protect its own children is feasible? Is there the national political will to contribute and invest in children in endemic countries, and not continue depending heavily on donors?

Malaria vaccines are a perfect example of what the 3 I’s can achieve. But beyond celebrating this addition to the malaria elimination toolkit, will we also be celebrating commitments by endemic countries of local funds to make zero malaria a reality?

By Jordan Kerr and originally posted in the Social and Behavioral Foundations of Primary Health Care Blog.

Malawi is making strides in increasing HPV vaccinations among adolescent girls across the nation. Since the official implementation of the HPV vaccine program in 2019, 20 out of the 29 districts in Malawi have begun administering the vaccine to adolescent girls between the age of 9 and 14. Despite this success, Malawi continues to be one of the leading countries worldwide in cervical cancer-related mortality. New cases of cervical cancer in Malawi are reported at a rate five times higher than the global average.

This highly preventable disease places a more significant burden on low-income countries like Malawi due to poor access to healthcare services and resources. International agencies are improving their outreach efforts to reach girls not enrolled in school and address vaccine hesitancy in districts with higher vaccine refusal rates. Due to this outreach vaccine registration is improving however healthcare facilities are experiencing stockouts. In some districts, healthcare facilities are reporting that the main reason individuals are not receiving vaccinations is that they are running out of vaccine stocks.

The World Health Organization (WHO) set a goal in 2018 to eliminate cervical cancer by increasing HPV vaccination uptake globally. This initiative has shown to be successful in addressing disparities in low- and middle-income countries however, in 2020 an HPV vaccination shortage began and is expected to continue through 2025.

The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) presents several strategies that can be used to address this shortage to keep on track with the goal to eliminate cervical cancer. Efforts must be taken to support facilities developing the HPV vaccine to ensure stockouts do not continue. We need policymakers to lobby for policies that increase funding for vaccination development and establish priority vaccination allocations to countries like Malawi that are experiencing high mortality rates from cervical cancer

By Blessing George & Chino Nduaka and originally posted in the Social and Behavioral Foundations of Primary Health Care Blog. More than 50% of deaths from malaria are from four African countries, and Nigeria heads the list, contributing a significant part at more than 30%. Nigeria faces a major public health burden, with an estimated 65 million cases and over 100,000 deaths in 2021, representing over 50% of malaria cases in West Africa. With most outpatient visits in Nigeria being caused by malaria, this disease has taken a toll on the economy. Malaria is among the top five causes of under-five mortality in Nigeria. Over the years, various organizations have joined hands in the fight against this deadly disease. However, Nigeria remains at the top of the list contributing significantly to the mortality rate. Insecticide-treated nets (ITNs), indoor residual spraying, and free sharing of anti-malaria drugs for prophylaxis and treatment constitute ways the country has tackled the disease burden. With the funding allocation repeatedly given by international organizations such as the WHO, the World Bank, and the Global Fund channeled to these interventions that have proved somewhat ineffective, we are at crossroads that begs the question, what next? In 2016, the world’s pioneer malaria vaccine, RTS, S, sold with the brand name, Mosquirix, was introduced for pilot implementation in three malaria-endemic countries. It has been administered to over a million children with positive results on its effectiveness. In 2022, the Nigerian government officially applied to receive the vaccine through GAVI but was hit back with the response that currently, there is an insufficient supply of vaccines. Nigeria tops the list of the global malaria mortality rate and should be prioritized. The Nigerian Ministry of Health, in collaboration with the Nigerian Primary Healthcare agency, needs to fight for the health of its citizens, respond to GAVI, and state the concrete reasons why the country should be prioritized. The goal is to ensure that these vaccines are made available for the under-5 population in Nigeria by 2025 such that in the malaria world report of 2030, Nigeria should not be named a major contributing country to malaria mortality.

Andaratu Wuni has contributed this posting to the Blog site for the JHU site for the course Social and Behavioral Foundations of Primary Health Care.

(Graphic source: https://www.aafp.org/news/health-of-the-public/20210429vacchesitancy.html)

Covid 19 has unarguably wrecked devastating consequences globally since its emergence and has proven to to be a ubiquitous public health health problem. Vaccination against the virus has been shown to be the most effective way of limiting severe disease and mortality. However the spate of vaccine hesitancy in Ghana has continued to rise in the last year. The World Health Organization defines vaccine hesitancy as the delay in acceptance or refusal of vaccination despite availability of vaccination services. This public health problem has far reaching consequences not only in Ghana but globally. Currently the vaccine hesitancy rate in Ghana is about 30% and counting! with people 25 years and under leading the hesitancy core.

(Graph Source: https://figshare.com/articles/thesis/Examining_drivers_of_COVID-19_vaccine_hesitancy_in_Ghana/14494851)

Since Ghana rolled out vaccines to the general public over one year ago, only 25.9% of the population have been fully vaccinated as of August 19,2022.Ghana has a target of vaccinating 22.9million eligible Ghanaians; that is about 60% of the population in order to achieve herd immunity, however only 8.2 million Ghanaians have been fully vaccinated to date.

Many reasons account for the rise in covid 19 vaccine hesitancy in Ghana; from the depletion of rigorous and continuous education and the consequent lack of community engagement, relaxation of covid 19 protocols, to vaccine misinformation and conspiracy theories as well as political influence. It is time for a policy that will mitigate this crucial problem, which the WHO(before the covid pandemic) described as one of the top ten greatest threats to global health.

The truth is, a single policy may not totally solve the problem as the issue of vaccine hesitancy is a complex one. The best approach will be for policymakers to enact policies to make vaccination a condition for other essential services in Ghana.

Intensify mandatory vaccination especially in high risk individuals and high risk locations, eliminate vaccine exemptions based on all but health related reasons, commit to structured community engagements and outreaches using the key stakeholders like the Ghana Medical Association and the Public Health association of Ghana, use stakeholders like UNICEF Ghana and the Ghana Health Service to disseminate accurate and scientifically proven vaccine information and last but not least introduce incentives for citizens who take the vaccine.

Edwin Chng has contributed this posting to the Blog site for the JHU site for the course Social and Behavioral Foundations of Primary Health Care.

Dengue has been endemic in Singapore for many decades, with all four dengue serotypes (DENV-1-4) in active circulation. It presents a significant impact on the economy, with the financial burden of dengue estimated to be US$1.04 billion from 2010 to 2020. (Mosquito Photo credit: http://bitly.ws/twG2)

Despite aggressive conventional vector control measures such as fogging and breeding site elimination, Singapore continues to have persistent outbreaks annually. The number of cases in recent years have also surged. From January to July 2022, 9 deaths and 22,468 cases have been reported thus far – the latter number is more than 4 times the number of cases reported in the whole of 2021. Dengue cases is likely to continue to increase, as the traditional peak dengue season in the country is from June to October each year. (Dengue Cases Graph Photo credit: NEA)

 

Singapore’s dengue crisis can be attributed to climate change and a recent change in the prevailing serotype. In the past, the dominant strains in Singapore were DENV-1 and DENV-2, hence the Singapore population has lower immunity to the other two strains. As a result, a large proportion of the population remains susceptible to DENV-3, which is emerging as the dominant strain in Singapore.

As such, as per the World Health Organization, dengue vaccination remains an integral part of dengue prevention and control strategy. The vaccine has an efficacy of about 80% against the outcomes of infection, hospitalization and severe infection which is potentially lethal. Unfortunately, the Singapore government has decided not to include it in the national immunization program, hence it is not eligible for government subsidy. As a result, the vaccine which costs a hefty USD450 remains inaccessible to the average Singaporean. (Vaccine Photo credit: http://bitly.ws/twGk).

Various stakeholders including the National Center for Infectious Diseases, primary care physicians and pharmaceutical companies can rally and work together in awareness campaigns and clinical studies. Health economics data from such collaborations can confirm the cost-effectiveness of dengue vaccines and positively influence the government to consider a change in its existing policy to provide subsidies. Increasing its accessibility and affordability to more Singaporeans will definitely contribute significantly to the fight against dengue in Singapore.