Mildred Komey Akosua,* James Sarkodie, Kezia Malm1 Raphael Ntumy, and Gladys Tetteh presented a poster entitled “Systematic Approach to the Review of Malaria Management Guidelines Ghana, 2019” at the 68th Annual Meeting of the American Society for Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.
The primary objective of the Ghana NMCP is to reduce morbidity & mortality due to malaria through effective strategies. Implementation of these effective malaria control strategies depends largely on the availability of up-to-date, evidence-based, and standardized reference materials to guide and improve practice. Guidelines for the management of malaria in Ghana, including the anti-malaria drug policy (ADP), guidelines for case management of malaria (CM) and guidelines for malaria in pregnancy (MiP) were last updated in 2014. The 2014 review took over six months and left behind no documented methodology to guide subsequent reviews.
The World Health Organization recommends a comprehensive review everyfive years. In order to make the 2019 review process concise, efficient and reproducible, the NMCP with support from the PMI Impact Malaria project outlined a methodical approach to the review.
The process established an oversight review committee; identified all stakeholders relevant to update the ADP and guidelines; prepared a reference package of technical resources and research findings; nominated experts and allocated them to topic-specific technical working groups (TWGs). (Fig 1)
Then, a series of TWG consultative meetings were held with clearly defined processes and outputs, and independent external experts and potential end users of the guidelines ratified the draft guidelines. (Fig 2 and Fig 3)
A final phase included development of training content, training manuals, and development of key job-aids. (Fig 4 and Fig 5) Costs for the review process were identified and funding obtained.
All components of the 2019 process were enhancements to the unrecorded 2014 review. The process resulted in a documented and costed methodological approach, an up-to-date ADP, MiP and CM guidelines, training curriculum, training manuals, and job aids; all developed in a timely and efficient manner over a three-month period.
It also resulted in an approach for achieving minor policy and guideline updates between comprehensive five-year reviews. Using a systematic well-defined comprehensive approach with clear expectations for inputs, process, outputs, roles, timelines, costs, and sequelae actions, results in up-to-date widely accepted policies and guidelines whose implementation can be easily operationalized, with mechanisms for minor guideline updates between comprehensive five-year reviews.
*Author affiliations: Ghana National Malaria Control Programme, PMI Impact Malaria Project, Jhpiego
Anjoli Anand,* Favero Rachel, Catherine Dentinger, A. Ralaivaomisa, S. Ramamonjisoa, Elaine Razafimandimby, Jocelyn Razafindrakoto, Katherine Wolf, Laura C. Steinhardt, Julie Thwing, Bryan K. Kapella, M. Rabary, Sedera Mioramalala, Jean Pierre Rakotovao presented a poster on “Malaria Case Management Practice and Elimination Readiness in Five Elimination Districts of Madagascar, 2018” at the 68th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. Their findings are shared below.
Madagascar’s Malaria National Strategic Plan 2018-2022 calls for progressive malaria elimination beginning in low-incidence districts (< 1 case/1000). Although an elimination plan has not yet been developed, optimizing access to prompt diagnosis and quality treatment will be its foundation, along with improving outbreak detection and response, and developing an elimination plan.
There was need to understand current practices in preparation for elimination such as estimating current implementation readiness, documenting current diagnosis and treatment practices (case management), Assessing the use of data to inform decision-making and determining the availability of commodities, training and supervision. To assess this readiness and inform planning, we surveyed health facilities (HFs) and communities.
In September 2018, we randomly selected 35 HFs in 5 of the 8 districts identified for elimination, surveyed 41 HWs and 34 community health volunteers (CHVs), and observed 300 clinical encounters between HWs and patients of all ages. Quantitative and qualitative tools were used to collect data. There were a health facility checklist, an interview guide for health facility providers, a clinical observation guide, a community health volunteer CHV) interview guide, and a stakeholder interview guide.
To evaluate elimination readiness, a composite score was assigned to each HF catchment area that incorporates all survey responses based on commodity availability, malaria CM practices, data management, and supervision practices.
In preliminary results, 8 of 34 (24%) CHVs reported that they do not manage children under 5 years (CU5) with fever at the community level. Of 26 CHVs who care for CU5, 18 (69%) identified history of fever as a criterion for suspected malaria, 20 (77%) reported using a malaria rapid diagnostic test (RDT) when evaluating patients reporting fever, and 15 (58%) reported giving antimalarials for a positive RDT. Among treating CHVs, 13 (30%) reported having RDTs, and 11 (42%) reported having antimalarials currently available. A
Among facility-based HWs, 83% identified history of fever as a criterion for a suspected case. Of 120 patients with reported or recorded fever, 56 (47%) were tested with an RDT. Five RDTs were positive; a first-line antimalarial was prescribed to 4 of those patients. This evaluation is a baseline for CM performance as Madagascar establishes elimination targets. In the evaluated districts, CM could be improved by strategies to increase testing at CHV and HF levels and address availability of commodity stocks in the community.
*Affiliations: Epidemic Intelligence Service, Malaria Branch, Division of Parasitic Diseases and Malaria, Center for Global Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, United States; Maternal Child Survival Program, Washington, DC, United States; US President’s Malaria Initiative; US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Antananarivo, Madagascar; Maternal Child Survival Program, Madagascar, Antananarivo, Madagascar; Maternal Child Survival Program, Antananarivo, Madagascar; US President’s Malaria Initiative, Antananarivo, Madagascar; Malaria Branch, Division of Parasitic Diseases and Malaria, Center for Global Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, United States; National Malaria Control Program, Antananarivo, Madagascar
Moumouni Bonkoungou,* Ousmane Badolo, Youssouf Sawadogo, Stanislas Nebie, Thierry Ouedraogo, Yacouba Sawadogo, William Brieger, Gladys Tetteh, and Blami Dao presented their work on “mMentoring, a New Approach to Improve Malaria Care in Burkina Faso” at the 68th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene as seen below.
Malaria is the leading cause of consultation (43.3%), hospitalization (44.1%) and death (16.1 %) in Burkina Faso. In the Sahel Region, the case fatality proportion due to malaria is 2% compared to 0.8% for the national average. This region is most affected by malaria than others. Also, the Sahel Region is currently experiencing high levels of insecurity making movement of health teams difficult and unsafe.
mMentoring is the use of mobile technology to ensure capacity building and continuing education among health staff. The process started by a workshop to develop messages, and briefing of the main actors.
Each week, messages and quizzes (An automatic answer is sent to each quiz) are sent to 753 providers (nurses, midwives, medical doctors) of the 115 health centers in the Sahel Region. Each month, messages are revised by a team at national level before being sent.
The messages sent were related to several key malaria prevention and control interventions, such as case definition, parasitological diagnosis, clinical case management of simple and severe cases, intermittent preventive treatment in pregnancy (IPTp), pre-referral treatment with rectal artesunate in children under 5 years, insecticide-treated bed nets.
After 10 months of implementation, 64 reinforcement messages on case management and prevention guideline and 63 quizzes were sent. Proportion of correct responses to the quizzes ranged from 43% and 96%. The lowest scores related to topics on management of severe cases while the highest were related to diagnosis of malaria.
The participation rate (number of respondents of the 753 targeted health workers) is on average 22% with 71% of participants from primary health facilities. Also, we notice IPT3 increased from 14.8% in the quarter 3 of 2017 to 45.6% in the same quarter of 2018 (with mMentoring).
The rate of performance of rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) rose from 67.5% to 77.8%. The case fatality rate during this quarter of 2017 was 3.3% and 1.8% in 2018. As a real platform for continuing training, it would be wise to extend this approach to other regions of the country and also to other health actors like community health workers.
*Affiliations: PMI Improving Malaria Care Project, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, Ministry of Health, National Malaria Control Program, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States, Jhpiego Baltimore, Baltimore, MD, United States
Malaria is an old disease, and not unfamiliar to the people of Lwala, Migori county, Nyanza province, situated in Kenya, East Africa. The most vulnerable are pregnant women and young children.The Lwala Community Alliance have reduced the rate of under 5 mortality to 20% of what it was 10 years ago, and about 30% of what it is in Migori county (reported 29 deaths/ 1000 in 2018) https://lwala.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Lwala-2018-Annual-Report.pdf
Of the scourges that remain, malaria is one of them.
The mosquito types responsible for malaria in the area are A. gambiae spp and A. arabiensis spp. To complete it’s life cycle, the mosquito requires water, or an aquatic environment to develop it’s larvae. This insect therefore seeks to lay it’s eggs in pools of fresh water, abundant in the area due to Lake Victoria, and important source of the local staple fish, and areas of underdeveloped grassland surrounding the lake and village. https://malariajournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1475-2875-9-62
WHO reported 219 million cases of malaria world wide, with 435,000 deaths in the same year. In this day and age, malaria remains burdensome in 11 countries, 10 of them being in Africa. WHO recommends a focused response. https:// who.int/malaria/en/. I advocate a focus on prevention by eradicating mosquitoes and episodes of mosquito bites in the region. WHO vector control guidelines run along the idea of chemical and biological larvicides, topical repellents,and personal protective measures, such as bed nets, wearing long sleeves and pants (hard to do in the heat of Migori), bug spray and insecticide treated nets. These are effective.
Let’s start by making sure they do by scaling up this program, so that the number of nets corresponds with the number of individuals per household.
Lwala is an active community, and while use of nets will eliminate night feeders such as A. gambiae , little children will be susceptible to mosquito bites given that they are outdoors nearly daily helping with activities such as fishing, goat herding, fetching water and so forth. That is why active programs for mosquito eradication make so much sense in the region. While promoting personal prevention measures such as the use of “bugspray” containing effective substances such as DEET, efforts by the Bill and Melissa gates foundation, through the Malaria R&D (research and development) active since 2004, have devoted over $323 million dollars, about 20% ($50.4 million) of which has gone to the Innovative Vector Control Consortium, (IVCC) led by the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine. The aim is to fast track improved insecticides, both biological and chemical, and other measures of vector control. I suggest that partnership with the IVCC be scaled up in the area, allowing Lwala to be first line in any benefits thereof. https://www.gatesfoundation.org/Media-Center/Press-Releases/2010/11/IVCC-Develops-New-Public-Health-Insecticides, https://www.gatesfoundation.org/Media-Center/Press-Releases/2005/10/Gates-Foundation-Commits-2583-Million-for-Malaria-Research
All these promote a healthy habitat for the mosquito during the rainy season, and easy entry and hiding places all year round. Funding to improve house types so that locally-sourced but sturdy, water-proof homes can be built, will eliminate opportunities for the mosquito to access and bite young children.
After the World’s first attempt at eradicating the
complicated disease malaria mainly through a single tool, a period of control
set in where the aim was to reduce mortality through prompt and presumptive
treatment of fevers with anti-malarials, particularly in young children. During
this period in the 1980s and 1990s it was recognized that parasite-based
diagnostic capabilities in the form of microscopy were limited, so in malaria
endemic areas, it was worth providing inexpensive medicines like chloroquine
(CQ) and sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) to febrile children in order to save lives.
When the fevers did not resolve, other illnesses explored.
The difficulty arose in identifying cases that did not offer
clinical clues that they might be malaria. Today countries approaching malaria
elimination face challenges, such as seen in Zanzibar where, “outdoor
transmission, a large asymptomatic parasite reservoir and imported infections,
require novel tools and reoriented strategies to prevent a rebound effect and
Here we examine the challenge of asymptomatic malaria infections.
By 1998 when the Roll Back Malaria partnership formed, there
had been enough research done so that the malaria community had a better
arsenal of interventions including insecticide-treated bed nets,
artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) and intermittent preventive
treatment with SP during pregnancy. The Abuja Declaration of 2000 set a target
of 80% coverage of these interventions by the year 2010.
While ACTs overcame the challenges of parasite resistance
that had developed for the single drugs, CQ and SP, it cost several times more
than those medicines. The need for easy-to-use, inexpensive, point-of-care
diagnostics was recognized so that not only would ACTs be targeted only to
parasitologically confirmed malaria cases, but also in the process, overuse and
misuse would not contribute to parasite resistance of these new drugs.[ii]
Unfortunately, the development and dissemination of antigen-based rapid
diagnostic tests (RDTs), lagged behind the availability of ACTs meaning that
health workers unfortunately continued their business as usual with presumptive
treatment using ACTs.
The benefits of RDTs were generally two-fold. First, they
could be used by front-line, auxiliary and community-based health workers.
Secondly, they tended to identify more cases than microscopy. The big challenge
was convincing health workers to use them and trust the results, because the
era of presumptive treatment had given these staff a false sense of confidence
in their own clinical diagnostic abilities.
Although reaching the 2010 coverage targets has remained
illusive for most endemic countries, there has been enough progress for major
reductions in incidence (despite a recent upsurge).[iii]
As the proportion of actual malaria cases among febrile illness patients
declines, concern has risen that transmission might continue among people with
subclinical or asymptomatic malaria. Here we explore the extent of this problem
and new directions in parasitological testing needed to ensure continued
progress toward elimination in each endemic country.
Understanding the Risk of Asymptomatic Malaria
Risk can relate to geographical, epidemiological, and socio-demographic factors as well as history of malaria interventions. Kenya has stratified the country by higher and lower malaria transmission areas. Even the higher areas are comparatively low compared to its higher transmission neighbors. Studying the prevalence of asymptomatic malaria in some of these higher transmission areas in the west of the country was seen as a way to better identify people at risk and learn about intervention effectiveness. An examination of apparently healthy children (no symptoms) revealed a Plasmodium falciparum malaria prevalence 36.0% (27.5%, 44.5%) by RDT and 22.3% (16.0%, 28.6%) by thick film microscopy.[iv] Living in a household with electricity was protective but the adjusted odds ratio of prevalence comparing households with and without indoor residual spray showed only borderline benefit. Unfortunately, in Zanzibar, asymptomatic malaria infection was not associated “with use of any vector control.”1
A major challenge in detecting cases through routine health
care systems is care seeking patterns of care seeking for fever. The 2018 World
Malaria Report acknowledges that there are major equity challenges in care
seeking wherein families with higher incomes, better education and living in
urban areas are more likely to seek help for their febrile children that rural,
poor and less educated families who would be more at risk. Care seeking without
the signs of fever is more challenging. A dual strategy of enabling better
service utilization as well as outreach to detect cases will be necessary to
detect asymptomatic cases.3
In Burkina Faso, the prevalence of asymptomatic malaria
infection in children under 5 years of age was estimated at 38.2% in 24 of its
70 health districts. Those at most risk for asymptomatic malaria infection
included the following:[v]
older children (48–59 vs < 6 months: OR: 6.79
children from very poor households (Richest vs
poorest: OR: 0.85 [0.74–0.96])
households located more than 5 km from a health
facility (< 5 km vs ? 5 km: OR: 1.14 [1.04–1.25])
localities with inadequate number of nurses
(< 3 vs ? 3: 0.72 [0.62, 0.82]
rural areas (OR: 1.67 [1.39–2.01])
Nine districts reported significantly higher risks (Batié,
Boromo, Dano, Diébougou, Gaoua, Ouahigouya, Ouargaye, Sapouy and Toma. The
researchers concluded that, “Such national spatial analysis should help to
prioritize areas for increased malaria control activities.”
A study in Ghana found that, “children and pregnant women had higher prevalence of submicroscopic gametocytes (39.5% and 29.7%, respectively) compared to adults (17.4%).”[vi]
An additional concern is emerging in terms of sharing of malaria parasite species between humans and primates, especially as urbanization and deforestation push these two populations into closer contact. For example Mapua and colleagues working in Central Africa Republic, “found the human malaria parasite P. ovale wallikeri in both asymptomatic humans and western lowland gorillas in Dzanga Sangha Protected Areas. Molecular analysis revealed that the genotype of the P. ovale wallikeri DNA found in a gorilla was genetically identical to that of a human isolate within the mt cytb and mt cox 1 genes, indicating potential human–ape transmission.”[vii] They noted similar sharing of parasites in the region between humans and chimpanzees.
Detecting and Responding to Asymptomatic Cases
WHO’s Framework for Malaria Elimination[viii]
recognizes the important role of case detection and subsequent treatment as
well as broader community level preventive responses around detected cases. In
the context of elimination WHO notes that case detection “requires use of
a diagnostic test to identify asymptomatic malaria infections.” WHO
stresses that a case is a case, regardless of whether it is symptomatic or
asymptomatic, as long as the diagnostic process confirms presence of malaria
It is important to monitor Plasmodium parasitemia in areas where malaria
transmission has declined and efforts to achieve malaria elimination are
underway, such as Zambia, where 3,863 household members were tested.[ix]
Only 2.6% were positive by either microscopy, RDT, or PCR. Of these, 48 (47%)
had subpatent parasitemia, and 85% of those with subpatent parasitemia were
asymptomatic. “Compared with individuals without parasitemia, individuals with
subpatent parasitemia were significantly more likely to be aged 5–25 years.”
The authors suggested that their findings pointed to the need for active or
reactive case detection to identify asymptomatic individuals and thus better
target individuals with subpatent parasitemia with appropriate malaria
WHO explains that active case detection (ACD) takes place in
areas of limited or under-utilization of health care services.4 It
may start with initial screening for symptoms, followed by appropriate
parasitological laboratory confirmation. In low-transmission settings or as
part of a focus investigation, “ACD may consist of testing of a defined
population group without prior symptom screening (population-wide or mass
testing) in order to identify asymptomatic infections.” Elimination cannot be
achieved until even asymptomatic infections have stopped. The challenge is the
expense of community-wide screening.
Reactive Case Detection (RCD), according to WHO, takes place
in settings low transmission intensity where the few “occurring malaria cases
are highly aggregated.”4 When a case is identified, usually through
identification of an actual infected patient at a local clinic, the community
where the patient comes from is visited and a “net is cast around the
index case” where household members and neighbors within a selected radius
are tested. In this process asymptomatic cases are also identified.
Our existing diagnostic tools may be inadequate. McCreesh
and colleagues reported on subpatent malaria in Namibia that, “fever
history and standard RDTs are not useful to address this burden. Achievement of
malaria elimination may require active case detection using more sensitive
point-of-care diagnostics or presumptive treatment and targeted to high-risk
groups.” This includes loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) using
dried blood spots, which they tested.[x]
Likewise from experience in a Zambian study, Kobayashi and co-researchers
suggest, “more sensitive diagnostic tests or focal drug administration may be
necessary to target individuals with subpatent parasitemia to achieve malaria elimination.”[xi]
Responses to detecting asymptomatic cases start at the
individual level with prompt treatment of those found through RCD to be
infected. Then focused preventive interventions such as distribution of
insecticide treated bednets can be provided to those in the cluster or village.
Follow-up would be needed for such ‘hot spots.’
On a broader basis we have Seasonal Malaria Chemoprevention
(SMC) as practiced in Sahelian countries where during the peak transmission
(rainy) season intermittent preventive treatment is given to children monthly
by community health workers and volunteers. Of course, many of these children
would be asymptomatic carriers and SMC could benefit the reduction of parasites
in circulation. At present SMC focuses on pre-school aged children, but Thera
and co-researchers stress the importance of reaching school aged children who
are also often asymptomatic carriers.[xii]
Another intervention being tested for mass drug
administration (MDA) use providing the community with ivermectin, a drug that
has been highly effective in controlling filarial diseases and also found to
kill mosquitoes who take a blood meal from a person who has recently taken it.[xiii]
This strategy is still being tested, but again MDA means all community members,
especially those with asymptomatic infection, would be reached.
A major question requires further research. To what extent
do asymptomatic, submicroscopic and subpatent parasitemia contribute to
continued malaria transmission? Another question is how can we address malaria
infection in other primates? We know that scientists recommend targeting of
malaria elimination interventions based on mapping of these infections.5
We therefore need to study the actual transmission potential of this
A, Shakely D, Ali AS, Morris U, Mkali H, Abbas AK, Al-Mafazy A-W, Haji KA, Mcha
J, Omar R, Cook J, Elfving K, Petzold M, Sachs MC, Aydin-Schmidt B, Drakeley V,
Msellem M and Mårtensson A. From high to low malaria transmission in
Zanzibar—challenges and opportunities to achieve elimination. BMC Medicine
(2019) 17:14, https://doi.org/10.1186/s12916-018-1243-z
Malaria Programme. Universal access to malaria diagnostic testing – An operational
manual. World Health Organization. November 2011 (rev. February 2013).
Malaria Programme. World malaria report 2018. World Health Organization. 19
November 2018. https://www.who.int/malaria/publications/world-malaria-report-2018/en/
S, Tenge C, Genga IO, Mumia M, Were PA, Kuremu RT, Wekes WN, Sumba PO, Kinyera T, Otim T, Legason ID,
Biddle J, Reynolds SJ, Talisuna AO, Biggar1 RJ, Bhatia K, Goedert JJ, Pfeiffer
RM, Mbulaiteye SM. A Cross-Sectional Population Study of Geographic,
Age-Specific, and Household Risk Factors for Asymptomatic Plasmodium falciparum
Malaria Infection in Western Kenya. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine
and Hygiene, Volume 100, Issue 1, Jan 2019, p.54-65. DOI:
Ouédraogo M, Samadoulougou S, Rouamba T, Hien H, Sawadogo JEM Tinto H, Alegana
VA, Speybroeck N and Kirakoya?Samadoulougou F. Spatial distribution and
determinants of asymptomatic malaria risk among children under 5 years in 24
districts in Burkina Faso. Malaria Journal 2018; 17:460
H, Ofori MF, Kusi KA, Adu B, Owusu-Yeboa E, Kyei-Baafour E, Arku AT, Bosomprah
S, Alifrangis M, Quakyi IA. The prevalence of submicroscopic Plasmodium
falciparum gametocyte carriage and multiplicity of infection in children,
pregnant women and adults in a low malaria transmission area in Southern Ghana.
Malar J. 2018 Sep 17;17(1):331. doi: 10.1186/s12936-018-2479-y.
MI, Hans-Peter Fuehrer HP, Petrželková KJ, Todd A, Noedl H, Qablan MA, and
Modrý D. Plasmodium ovale wallikeri in Western Lowland Gorillas and Humans
Central African Republic. Emerging Infectious Disease journal. Volume 24,
Number 8—August 2018. https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/24/8/18-0010_article
Global Malaria Programme. A framework for malaria elimination. ISBN
978-92-4-151198-8. World Health Organization 2017, http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/atoz/9789241511988/en/
T, Kanyangarara M, Laban NM, Phiri M, Hamapumbu H, Searle KM, Stevenson JC,
Thuma PE, Moss WJ and the Southern Africa International Centers of Excellence
for Malaria Research. Characteristics of Subpatent Malaria in a Pre-Elimination
Setting in Southern Zambia. The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and
Hygiene, 10 December 2018, DOI: https://doi.org/10.4269/ajtmh.18-0399
P, Mumbengegwi D, Roberts K, Tambo M, Smith J, Whittemore B, Kelly G, Moe C,
Murphy M, Chisenga M, Greenhouse B, Ntuku H, Kleinschmidt I, Sturrock H, Uusiku
P, Gosling R, Bennett A, Hsiang MS. Subpatent malaria in a low transmission
African setting: a cross-sectional study using rapid diagnostic testing (RDT)
and loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) from Zambezi region, Namibia.
Malar J. 2018 Dec 19;17(1):480. doi: 10.1186/s12936-018-2626-5.
T, Kanyangarara M, Laban NM, Phiri M, Hamapumbu H, Searle KM, Stevenson JC,
Thuma PE, Moss WJ, For The Southern Africa International Centers Of Excellence
For Malaria Research.Characteristics of Subpatent Malaria in a Pre-Elimination
Setting in Southern Zambia. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2018 Dec 10. doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.18-0399.
[Epub ahead of print]
[xii] Thera MA, Konea AK, Tangaraa B, Diarraa E, Niarea A, Dembeleb A, Sissokoa MS, Doumboa OK. School-aged children based seasonal malaria chemoprevention using artesunate-amodiaquine in Mali. Parasite Epidemiology and Control 3 (2018) 96–105. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.parepi.2018.02.001
Smit MR, Ochomo EO, Aljayyoussi G, Kwambai TK, Abong’o BO, Chen T, Bousema T,
Slater HC, Waterhouse D, Bayoh NM, Gimnig JE, Samuels AM, Desai MR,
Phillips-Howard PA, Kariuki SK, Wang D, Ward SA, ter Kuile FO. Safety and
mosquitocidal efficacy of high-dose ivermectin when co-administered with
dihydroartemisinin-piperaquine. www.thelancet.com/infection Published online
March 27, 2018 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S1473-3099(18)30163-4
Management Sciences for Health notes
that, “PBF is a powerful means for increasing the quantity and quality of
health services by providing incentives to health providers to improve
performance. A PBF program typically includes performance?based grants or
contracts. Health clinics and their staff are rewarded for reaching or
exceeding health indicators.” MSH cautioned that, “while PBF is expected to
reduce unit costs in the long?term by increasing productivity, unit costs may
actually increase in the short term when services have previously been
underfunded???as salaries rise to appropriate levels, missing equipment and
supplies are purchased, and facilities are upgraded.” In the long term they
explained that PBF had a, “crucial impact on revenues received at health
centers, motivated access to quality services for the people served, and
allowed the Government of Rwanda to actively manage its investments in pursing
national health goals.”
Between 2001 and the mid-2000s Rwanda introduced and began scaling up PBF. The focus of health care shifted from inputs to outputs to outcomes. “Performance improvements that have been documented in Rwanda after the introduction of performance incentives for primary health care and HIV/AIDS service products have been impressive.” In two pilot districts health care consultations per capita more than doubled. Institutional deliveries tripled. Child immunization, maternal immunization and contraceptive prevalence rates also increased.
There is national policy and political support for PBF as it
fits into government desired for accountability. Financial support comes from
government and specific programs within the Ministry of Health such as malaria
elimination and TB control who have invested in specific performance
indicators. Donors such as USAID, World Bank, and Global Fund, play a major
role in providing the technical and financial support that pays for
PBF in Rwanda operates at all levels of the health system,
but of interest to PHC are the front-line health centers and the local
cooperatives and community health workers (CHWs). CHW support came about in
2008 as a strategy to sustain the CHWs system. PBF in Rwanda is based on two
kinds of contracts, contracts on the performance of the health unit and
contracts on the performance of individual health workers.
The PBF procedures manual
explains that, “Community PBF (C-PBF) is implemented at the village level
through the trained community health workers (CHW) operational within each
community. Health posts are located at the cell level and due to their private
or faith-based organizations affiliation they are not integrated into the PBF
system. Health Center PBF is implemented at the sector’s level health center
while district and provincial hospitals are implementing the district hospital
PBF model (recently linked with accreditation).”
Under the USAID MCHIP Project, Jhpiego conducted a malaria
program implementation assessment in Rwanda that examined the health systems
building blocks including financing. The report noted that, “Cooperatives have
been set up for CHW; there are usually about 120 people (depending on the
number of CHWs in the catchment area of the health center) per cooperative with
a president, vice president, secretary, treasurer, and three advisors.
Cooperatives can engage in many different types of income-generating
activities, based on the agreement among the members, and the executive
committee makes final decisions and determines how income will be disbursed
The aspect of PBF contracting is undertaken with the CHW
Cooperative. “Through the PBF, CHW cooperatives can earn ~250USD per quarter
from the government. The total amount is based on the completeness of CHW
reports and their performance on 20 set indicators. These indicators include
elements such as timeliness and completeness of reports, number of pregnant
women receiving consultation in the first trimester, number of women accepting
family planning (new and continuing clients), and infant growth monitoring.”
Rwanda has also introduced a quality of services element
known as Pay-4-Performance, and entities such as health centers and CHW
cooperatives are also given a quality score arising from supervisory processes.
The quality component has helped “cooperatives linked to the PBF address issues
of attrition and motivation. The division of supervision among cell leaders
also reduces the work burden for facility-based supervisors.” Practical service
delivery problems such as stock-outs of commodities are less likely to occur at
the community level when PBF is in place. The challenge moving forward may be the
stress created by adding more responsibilities to the duties of the CHWs.
The MCHIP report concluded that, “PBF has set up a system of
accountability so that not only is funding spent appropriately, but results are
also expected and rewarded. PBF addresses the challenges of motivation that so
often plague health care workers and managers in other countries who do not see
rewards for working hard and doing a good job. The fact that the system of
emphasis on quality services in sufficient quantities radiates from the
national to the district to the community level (i.e., districts reporting to
the President’s office, and CHWs reporting on indicators to health center
supervisors) ensures that a culture of rewarding good performance is
developing.” A systems challenge is dependence on donor support in terms of
both continuity and donor focus, as many donors focus on particular
interventions (malaria, family planning), leaving gaps among the service
Sciences for Health. The Health Impact of Performance-Based Financing in
Rwanda. Published: 2010?12?23 http://blog.msh.org/2010/12/23/the-health-impact-of-performance-based-financing-in-rwanda/
Louis Rusa, (National PBF Coordinator-Ministry of Health Rwanda), and Gyuri
Fritsche, (Health Care Financing Specialist-Management Sciences for Health). Rwanda:
Performance-Based Financing in Health. Sourcebook: Second Edition.
Ministry of Health, Rwanda. Performance Based Financing Procedures Manual for
Health Facilities (Hospitals and Health Centers). April 2018.
and Child Health Intergrated Program (USAID, Jhpiego). Analysis of the Status
of Prevention and Control of Malaria in Rwanda: Best Practices and Challenges
to Program Implementation. November 2013.
In the 1990s the Navrongo research center started the
Community-based Health Planning and Services (CHPS) initiative 3 pilot
districts. The CHPS Initiative has now become the national strategy for
implementing community-based service delivery by reorienting and relocating
primary health care from sub-district health centers to convenient community
CHPS is even seen as crucial to Ghana’s broader poverty reduction agenda and
The CHPS Operational Policy notes that, CHPS was designed to
operate at the third tier of the district health system that encompassed a
district hospital, sub-district health centers and community-based services by addressing
the needs of zones of 3000-4,500 residents “where primary health care
services will be provided to the population by a resident Community Health
Officer (CHO) assisted by the Community structures and volunteer systems. The
deployment of all elements necessary for the CHO to provide house-to house
service shall make that zone a fully functional CHPS zone within the
sub-district,” thus creating CHPS compounds. It is the CHO who represents
the human resource innovation in the Ghana system
A CHO engages each Community within the zone in micro
planning of health activities termed “community decision making systems,”
building on the following key elements: Community (as social capital); Households
and individuals (as target); Planning with the community (community
participation); and Service delivery with the community (client focused).
Community health nurses (CHN) trained in the nation’s
various schools of nursing would be designated a CHO once they were posted to a
CHPS compound. The CHPS compound, often a building donated by the community or
a philanthropist served as a health post and accommodation for the CHO. There
could be two CHOs and a trained midwife, since CHNs are not trained to conduct
delivery. The CHOs are expected to deliver a package of essential primary
health care and promotion services at the community level that revolves around
home visiting. The idea is to take services to the clients.
While the curriculum of a CHN addresses some basic issues of
the CHPS program, CHNs do not exit school as ready-made CHOs. Those who opt to
become CHOs must receive orientation from the regions and districts where they
work in a CSPS. Depth and quality of orientation varies. CHOs could be assisted
by community health volunteers who are supervised by a community health
Sacks et al.
report that CHNs obtain a Certificate in Community Health Nursing as part of
pre-service training after completing a 2-year curriculum post-secondary
After 3-5 years of service, CHNs can enroll for higher education to become a
midwife or public health nurse (PHN). Sacks and colleagues found that CHN/CHO
satisfaction was often determined by professional isolation and lack of basic
resources and materials to perform their jobs.
By 2002, 95 out of 110 districts had launched the CHPS
program, though not every potential zone was covered. The rapid national
expansion of the CHPS program may have contributed to some of the CHNs’
frustrations, as the time was not taken to recruit and train health workers
from the target communities who would have spoken the same language. Facilities
were not upgraded prior to the increase of health workers and communities were
not prepared to provide free housing to CHNs, as originally planned, say Sacks
and co-researchers. Although the original goal was for CHPS to achieve complete
national coverage by 2015 through the establishment of 6,000 CHPS zones,
challenges led to completion of only 3,000 CHPS zones by then. Now, more than 20 years after the initial
trial, Ghana is re-launching the CHPS policy to elevate PHC as a priority and to
expand the CHPS model to parts of the country that are not yet covered.
The three broad areas of work by the CHO include basic primary
health care issues such as promotion and prevention, management of minor or
common ailment and their referrals and case detection, mobilization and
referrals. Ghana Web reports that,
CHPS compounds cover all 8 essential PHC services and aim at helping ensure
improved access to primary health care in these communities. For proper
functioning of the various CHPS compounds, there is very strong community
participation in the implementation.
The article reports that, “Where there is strong community
participation, traditional leaders and community members provide resources,
both financial and non-financial incentives, to support implementation of the
program. A CHO is expected to work in partnership with the community,
households and district assemblies to ensure that, citizens are able to access
services and health information as and when they need them whereas the
communities are expected to also exert some levels of answerability to health
The Upper West Region serves as an example of CHPS and CHOs implementation
as reported by the Ghana News Agency.
There are 308 functional CPHS zones out of 361 planned which cover 62% of the
population. The region had 364 CHOs in the 308 functioning zones and 305 active
community committees, with 1,669 volunteers. Unfortunately, only 155 of the
functioning CHPS zones were fully equipped to standard. A relaunch of CHPS will
focus on performance guidelines, systems strengthening and quality of services
Community-Based Health Planning and Services (CHPS): The Operational Policy,
Ghana Health Service, Policy Document No.20, May 2005.
Emma Sacks, Soumya Alva, Sophia Magalona and Linda Vesel. Examining domains of community
health nurse satisfaction and motivation: results from a mixed-methods baseline
evaluation in rural Ghana. Sacks et al. Human Resources for Health (2015)
13:81, DOI 10.1186/s12960-015-0082-7
John Koku Awoonor-Williams, Elisabeth Tadiri, and Hannah Ratcliffe .
Translating research into practice to ensure community engagement for
successful primary health care service delivery: The case of CHPS in Ghana.
Gabriel Frimpong. The Community-Based Health Planning and Service (CHPS)
concept in Ghana, Ghana Web. Tuesday, 24 April 2018.
Prosper K. Kuorsoh, Upper West Region has 62 per cent CHPS coverage. Ghana News
Agency. Thursday 9th August, 2018.
Community-Based Health Insurance (CBHI) is seen as a way to promote universal health coverage and protect vulnerable populations from catastrophic financial effects of illness. Malaria can be such an illness is not treated in a timely manner, and having insurance can help prevent delays.
In countries including Rwanda, Burkina Faso and Senegal a particular CBHI scheme known as mutuelles has taken root. For Rwanda USAID (2018) reports that …
The 2014–2015 DHS showed that insurance coverage has remained stable since the 2010DHS and that 79 percent of the households have at least one family member with health insurance and that among those insured 97 percent have community health insurance (mutuelles). Early ANC attendance is also encouraged by providing targeted SBCC, combined with innovative community- and facility-level performance-based financing and high enrollment in community health insurance schemes (mutuelles). The MoH, with the support of partners, has worked to improve the quality of services for case management at health facilities through training and capacity building efforts at national and district levels.
A study looked at health care seeking for children below 5years of age in Rwanda in 2005 to 2010 and found that, “In both years,under-five children with Mutuelles were more likely to use medical care than uninsured children. Children in 2010 had a higher probability of using medical care … regardless of the children’s poverty or Mutuelles status.” The study provides an example of how pre-payment CBHI can not only increase universal health coverage but also address challenges of equity (Mejía-Guevara et al., 2015).
Below is a chart showing the fee structure in Rwanda (Tashobya, 2017). [The trainer should ask participants about fees for CBHIs or other national health insurance schemes in their countries if such exist and how participation in CHBI helps achieve UHC.]
Fees in Rwanda’s community insurance scheme, Mutuelles
Rwandan Francs per Household Member
0 (Paid by
Now The East African reports that, “With more than 90 per
cent of Rwandans covered under the community-based health insurance scheme
locally known as Mutuelle de Santé, Rwanda is one of the few developing
countries in the world that have successfully achieved universal healthcare”
(Kagire, 2018) This was achieved by addressing enrollment, quality of cane and transferring
management of the scheme to the Rwanda Social Security Board (RSSB). Now more
than ever, no one needs to die from malaria in Rwanda.
Kagire, Edmund (2018). Rwanda Has Achieved
Universal Healthcare. The East African. 15 December 2018.
Mejía-Guevara I, Hill K, Subramanian SV, Lu C.
(2015). Service availability and association between Mutuelles and medical care
usage for under-five children in rural Rwanda: a statistical analysis with
repeated cross-sectional data. BMJ Open. 2015 Sep 8;5(9):e008814. doi:
Tashobya, Athan (2017). Mutuelle Month: Govt
targets 100% subscription. The New Times. Published : April 03, 2017.
USAID/President’s Malaria Initiative (2018)
Rwanda Malaria Operational Plan FY19. https://www.pmi.gov/docs/default-source/default-document-library/malaria-operational-plans/fy19/fy-2019-rwanda-malaria-operational-plan.pdf?sfvrsn=3
A changing climate, even a warming climate, does not directly translate into greater malaria transmission.[i] Lafferty and Mordecai explain that we need a need “a greater appreciation for the economic and environmental factors driving infectious diseases,” as these have their own impact on transmission.[ii] Climate change effects occur in parallel to “changes such as land conversion, urbanization, species assemblages, host movement, and demography.” This wider ecological understanding is needed to “predict which diseases are most likely to emerge where, so that public health agencies can best direct limited disease control resources.”
As the WHO framework for malaria elimination stresses, [iii] “Most countries have diverse transmission intensity, and factors such as ecology, immunity, vector behaviour, social factors and health system characteristics influence both the diversity of transmission and the effectiveness of tools, intervention packages and strategies in each locality.” The Framework goes further to encourage strategic planning and interventions appropriate for the diverse settings or strata within a country. What climate change implies is that the nature of malaria transmission in these strata will change as temperature, rainfall, humidity and human response change. Countries not only need to adapt malaria activities to existing strata, but also be alert to changes in transmission and thus changes needed in strategies.
Increased or decreased vector control activities would be one example of changes that are needed in response to climate, vector habitat and transmission changes. “The receptivity of an area (to vector control interventions) is not static but is affected by determinants such as environmental and climate factors.” Case detection will become even more crucial as transmission drops and the success of elimination programs depends on identifying, tracing and responding to remaining cases promptly and accurately.
The landscape for malaria control and elimination is shifting in part because of the success of interventions since the dawn of Roll Bank Malaria in 1998. As we have shown here, there may also be shifts due to climate change. Of great concern is the shifts that expose new and more vulnerable populations, such as those in the East Africa highlands to the threat of malaria. National Malaria Programs need strong surveillance efforts that monitor disease, vectors and climate, and be ready to respond.
Norohaingo Andrianaivo, Eliane Razafimandimby, Jean Pierre Rakotovao, Marc Eric Rajaonarison Razakariasy, and Lalanirina Ravony share their presentation on ensuring standardized malaria in pregnancy service delivery in Madagascar. The poster was viewed at the 66th Annual Meeting of the American Society of Tropical
Malaria is endemic in 90% of Madagascar. However, the entire population is considered to be at risk for the disease, with pregnant women particularly vulnerable. Madagascar adopted the IPT in pregnancy policy in 2004.
The Malaria Indicator Survey in 2016 in Madagascar showed only 10% of Malagasy pregnant women receiving three doses of SP (IPT3). MCSP previously conducted health provider training in antenatal care in workshop style, with usually one provider per facility attending each training.
To increase the number of providers offering standardized service according to the new WHO recommendations for IPTp, in 2016 MCSP Madagascar began implementing a new low dose/high frequency training approach, with routine supportive supervision. On-site training and supportive supervision provide the opportunity for the trainer and providers to discuss the barriers to delivery of IPTp-SP.
Additionally, with the addition of a new IPTp indicator in the facility dashboard, the trainer/supervisor can monitor the indicator, and discuss plan of action with providers as needed. To date, in Moramanga District, 16 providers in six facilities have benefited from this performance improvement approach.
The qualitative and quantitative study of provider performance and results from January 2017 to May 2017 shows that Providers do follow the WHO’s new recommendations on IPT. Adequate action plans were implemented to prevent SP stock out and to commit community health workers.
The increase of antenatal care utilization rate in these facilities. The IPT uptake increased This intervention is expected to show that IPT uptake and other maternal and newborn outcomes are improving in Madagascar.
This poster was made possible by the generous support of the American people through the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), under the terms of the Cooperative Agreement AID-OAA-A-14-00028. The contents are the responsibility of the Maternal and Child Survival Program and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government.